TDL Administration Reviews #7 | Fandom

This post is locked.

South Ferry·1/10/2020 in Administrative

TDL Administration Reviews #7

This thread is where the seventh administration review will be held. Occurring every six months, the administration review allows the community to give their input on all the staff members.

In order to participate, please use one of the following options to vote on a staff member:

Keep/Support - This means you want the staff member to remain in their position.

Neutral - This grants the staff member 1/2 a keep and 1/2 a removal vote. Remove/Oppose - This means you want the staff member to be completely removed from their position.

Suspend - This means you want the staff member to have their rights removed and then returned after a period of time. It is recommended to indicate how long you want the staff member removed.

Demote - This means you want the staff member to be demoted to a lower position, but not lose all of their rights. It is recommended to indicate the user right you want the staff member demoted to.

At least 67% of votes in favor of a removal, suspension, or demotion are required in order for them to occur. Staff members cannot vote for themselves.

Please keep discussion and votes civil. Critique is allowed and welcome, but please make it constructive. If you are a staff member, do not pressure users to support you. Grudge votes will not be counted. The seventh administration review ends on January 24, 2020 at 11:59:59 PM EST.

Below is the list of current staff members. This will be updated with totals as the administration review goes on.

Downtown Freezy - 6 support, 5 neutral

Qstlijku - 3 support, 2 remove, 2 demote to Assistant, 4 neutral

South Ferry - 12 support

TheKorraFanatic - 11 support

(Edited by South Ferry)

4

Downtown Freezy·1/10/2020

Qstlijku - Very weak, lightly salted REMOVE. Qst has, while productive in the past, been stagnant lately with no interest in conversations on the chat, the content of the wiki, or the community itself. I would say to demote him to a content moderator position, but I feel as though his work has been too few and far between to justify that.

South Ferry - Strong support. Good presence on chat, the wiki, active staff member who proposes policies and helps the rest of the staff come to decisions.

TheKorraFanatic - Immensely powerful, unlimited support. TheKorraFanatic has never allowed his position to stagnate and is constantly thinking of amendments to outdated policies, changes to wiki format, and other important things befitting his position. Really, I suppose that nobody else is more fit for this staff position.

1

TheKorraFanatic·1/10/2020

Downtown Freezy - strong support

Freezy has come a long way since the last AR and improved upon every criticism had of his chat moderation, is always active in RP discussions, and #staff-chat. If he began to edit more, I'd say his potential to grow on this wiki is unlimited.

Qstlijku - support

I suppose it is true that Qstlijku has not been that active recently and that he often doesn't participate in conversations lately. However, I am giving him support as I'd like to give him the chance to see the reviews of him this round and improve from them. I'd say that his activity /has/ improved as well. He's been coming to chat more often lately, using his tools recently, and participating in conversations both on chat, in TDLD, and #staff-chat.

The admin team is rather small right now and all help is important, even if he doesn't use his tools as often as he used to. Per above, he has still helped with blocking trolls and cleaning up Discussions lately and I think he could do better given a chance.

South Ferry - strong support

Ferry is a great bureaucrat, always active in editing and helping to lead the way in tough and long editing tasks, episode rewrites, and wiki projects. In staff discussions, he's often a voice of reason and his input is always crucial to decisions. He has done a great job as bureaucrat and I don't really have any criticism of him (OTHER than he shouldn't go silent for days, but (shark).)

(Edited by TheKorraFanatic)

3

Endercat TM·1/10/2020

Downtown Freezy - weak support: Freezy definitely has improved. He is more collected in chat and he helps a lot with work in the Wiki. He has added stuff to the RP and helped it grow. He acts more like a mod when needed than a user. I congratulate him and encourage him to continue this behavior.

Qstlijku - demote to Assistant: Q has been more active in the past and has always helped. Recently, though, he hasn’t been that active. I do not blame him though, as he must have his reasons for being inactive. And he has been making the effort the appear more often. And, TheKorraFanatic did mention he helped clean up the wiki and block trolls. But the Staff team needs as much help as it can get right now. Therefore, I don’t think he should stay admin but simply be demoted to Assistant, for the time being. I will, however, acknowledge the work that he has done and I hope he will continue helping as he can.

South Ferry - strong support: South Ferry has helped tremendously with RP and this wiki. He is continuously helping it to expand and grow. He edits a lot and helps with planning. He is one of the most important members of this Wiki and he is needed.

TheKorraFanatic - vehemently strong support: TheKorraFanatic is, and hopefully with always be, one of the most prominent Staff members I’ve ever seen. He is constantly helping the Wiki grow, he is constantly editing, he is constantly doing work. He is consistently active. He is one of - and probably the best - Staff members here. His behavior is also exemplary, with him being serious at times when he needs to be serious and joking at times when he can be joking. I congratulate him and hope he stays like this.

(Edited by Endercat TM)

3

Chase McFly·1/10/2020

Downtown Freezy-Neutral leaning towards support

South Ferry: Support

TheKorraFanatic: Support

Qstlijku: Remove

1

GTAFan86·1/10/2020

Downtown Freezy: Support

South Ferry: Support

TheKorraFanatic: Support

Qstlijku: Neutral

2

Messenger of Heaven·1/10/2020

Downtown Freezy: Neutral

I have not been active enough to see rather or not his behavior as changed since last AR but he has helped majorly with rewriting wiki pages.

South Ferry: Support

South has always been active, respectful and helpful on the wiki so he has my full support.

Qstlijku: Support

While he might not be as active as some would like He is helpful when needed so I vote support because the wiki does need him.

TheKorraFanatic: Support

2

SparkyBoi45·1/10/2020

Downtown Freezy: Support

TheKorraFanatic: Support

He has led this wiki to the best of his ability, always making sure that the wiki stays on track. He gives great ideas and I hope he has more of them

South Ferry: Support

He has always been active and helpful. He is always ready to work hard, and is respectful to his fellow users.

Qstlijku: Neutral

2

Qstlijku·1/10/2020

Downtown Freezy: Support

Freezy has definitely shown a lot of improvement since the last AR. I'm not of aware of any other issues, so Freezy has my support.

TheKorraFanatic, South Ferry: Strong Support

As the bureaucrats of TDL, they do an excellent job with their responsibilities and are good at keeping everything running smoothly all around.